Some authors find the staining capricious and unreliable2.
Positive in proximal rather than distal normal renal tubules3.
primary renal cell carcinoma |
clear cell |
59/70(solid 56/62, cystic 3/8), 5/6 (granular [eosinophilic] variant: the negative case was Fuhrman grade IV)4 |
papillary |
56/58 (papillary adenoma 4/4, papillary carcinoma 52/54) |
|
chromophobe |
5/11 (typical variant 5/8, eosinophilic variant 0/3), 0/114 |
|
sarcomatoid |
||
collecting duct |
0/9 |
|
overall |
122/153 (80%) |
|
metastatic renal cell carcinoma |
42/63 (67%) |
|
other primary renal tumours |
0/64 (oncocytoma 0/15, transitional cell carcinoma 0/20, mesoblastic nephroma 0/3, cystic nephoma 0/3, lymphoma 0/8, angiomyolipoma 0/3, mixed stromal and epithelial tumour 0/4, nephroblastoma 0/8) , 0/12(oncocytoma)4 |
|
non-renal primary tumours |
breast |
5/15
|
parathyroid adenoma |
8/8 |
|
testicular embryonal carcinoma |
2/7 |
|
others |
0/116
|
|
non-renal metastatic carcinomas |
breast |
2/19 |
other |
0/89
|
|
Differentiating primary or metastatic renal cell carcinoma from non-renal tumour
The differential diagnosis of eosinophilic renal tumours: granular variant of renal cell carcinoma, chromophobe renal cell carcinoma and oncocytoma.
References
This page last revised 17.7.2005.
©SMUHT/PW Bishop